Why Do Different Tarot Readers Give Contrasting Answers To The Same Question: The Variance In Tarot Readings Explained

card meanings

In the enigmatic realm of tarot, seekers often encounter a fascinating phenomenon: different readers offering disparate insights to the same inquiry. This intriguing variability in interpretations has sparked curiosity and at times perplexity, leaving many to wonder why such diversity exists within the realm of tarot readings. To unravel this mystique, one must delve into the intricate layers that shape the art of tarot reading and explore why each reader provides a distinct perspective on the same cards.

The Dynamic Nature of Interpretation

Within the intricate tapestry of tarot readings, lies the captivating essence of interpretation. At its core, tarot is a language—a rich, symbolic lexicon that speaks through archetypes, images, and metaphors. The cards themselves bear layers of meaning, woven into their ancient symbolism and historical significance. However, it’s the dynamic interaction between the cards and the reader that brings forth the myriad interpretations.

Each tarot deck comprises a collection of images—symbols that possess universal resonance yet remain open to personal interpretation. A single card can evoke a multitude of emotions, memories, and thoughts, acting as a mirror reflecting the reader’s unique experiences and intuitive insights. As such, the meanings attributed to these cards are fluid, malleable to the individual perceptions and connections of the reader.

Moreover, the context in which a reading occurs amplifies this dynamism. The same card, drawn in different spreads or in response to varying questions, can manifest diverse messages. The juxtaposition of cards within a spread creates a narrative, a story unfolding through the interactions between these symbols. Thus, the meaning of a card not only rests on its individual symbolism but also on its relationship with the surrounding cards, echoing the fluidity of life itself.

Furthermore, the temporal aspect adds layers to interpretation. Tarot readings capture moments in time, providing insights into the present while hinting at potential futures. The same card drawn today might hold different implications tomorrow, mirroring the ever-changing nature of existence.

In essence, the dynamic nature of tarot interpretation stems from the fusion of the cards’ inherent symbolism and the kaleidoscope of the reader’s experiences, emotions, and intuition. It is this fusion that breathes life into the cards, transforming them from mere images into profound conduits of insight and guidance.

For instance, consider the High Priestess card. To one reader, she embodies intuition, divine knowledge, and the mysteries of the subconscious mind. To another, she might represent the need for introspection, a call to delve into the depths of one’s psyche for hidden truths. Her presence in a spread might signify the importance of tapping into one’s inner wisdom, guiding the seeker to trust their instincts and inner guidance.

This inherent flexibility in interpretation allows tarot readings to resonate deeply with seekers, providing nuanced insights that speak directly to their unique situations and inner landscapes. It’s this interplay between the fixed symbolism of the cards and the ever-evolving interpretations of the reader that fosters the enchanting diversity within tarot readings.

Factors Shaping Interpretation

The kaleidoscope of interpretations in tarot readings is intricately woven by an array of influential factors that shape the lens through which a reader perceives the cards.

1. Personal Background and Experience

A pivotal force shaping tarot interpretation is the reader’s individual background. Their life experiences, cultural upbringing, and personal beliefs imbue the readings with unique hues. A reader with a background in mythology might delve into the archetypal aspects of the cards, while someone steeped in folklore may interpret them through cultural symbolism.

2. Psychological and Spiritual Perspectives

Tarot readers often draw from diverse disciplines such as psychology, spirituality, mysticism, or even science. This amalgamation of knowledge influences their interpretation. For instance, a reader with a psychological orientation might focus on the cards as tools for introspection and self-analysis, while a spiritually inclined reader might see them as channels for divine guidance and cosmic energies.

3. Intuition and Connection

Intuition forms an integral part of tarot readings. A reader’s intuitive insights, often honed through practice and experience, play a significant role in deciphering the nuances of the cards. The personal connection a reader feels with a particular deck or card can deeply influence their interpretation, as it resonates on a more profound, intuitive level.

4. Context and Questioning

The context within which a reading is conducted and the nature of the question asked greatly impact the interpretation. The same card drawn in response to queries about relationships, career, or personal growth can evoke varied insights. The reader navigates these nuances, allowing the cards to reflect the essence of the query.

For instance, the appearance of the Three of Swords, depicting heartache and sorrow, might be interpreted diversely. In one reading, it might signify emotional pain and heartbreak in a relationship, prompting the seeker to address issues with empathy and understanding. In another context, it could symbolize the necessity of healing from past traumas or letting go of emotional burdens that hinder personal growth.

Or, for instance, drawing the Tower card in response to a relationship question might suggest a need for upheaval and transformation, while inquiring about career prospects could signify sudden changes or upheavals in the workplace.

The fusion of these multifaceted factors shapes the kaleidoscopic nature of tarot readings, as each reader synthesizes their knowledge, intuition, and contextual understanding to craft a narrative through the cards. Understanding these influential elements provides insight into the intricate web of meanings woven into each reading, enhancing the richness and depth of the tarot experience.

Examples of Divergent Interpretations

Consider the multifaceted interpretations of the Death card. While some readers associate it solely with physical death, others perceive it as a symbol of transformative change or the end of a cycle. For instance, one reader might interpret the Death card as the end of a stagnant phase, urging the seeker to embrace change for personal growth. In contrast, another might view it as a representation of rebirth and new beginnings, signaling the start of a transformative journey.

Similarly, the Fool card can be perceived diversely. One reader might see it as a call for spontaneity and taking risks, advocating for embracing opportunities without fear. Conversely, another reader might emphasize the Fool’s innocence and naivety, cautioning the seeker to approach situations with care and mindfulness.

With the Seven of Cups a reader might interpret the card of choices and illusions. It could signify a need for focus amid numerous options or warning against being carried away by unrealistic dreams or fantasies. However, another interpretation might highlight the card’s association with creative visualization and the power of imagination. It could encourage the seeker to explore their dreams and desires, suggesting that some illusions hold the potential to manifest into reality with focused intent.

And similar with the Five of Pentacles, the card often symbolizes hardship and financial struggles. One reader may interpret it as a period of scarcity or feeling left out in the cold, urging the seeker to seek support during challenging times. Alternatively, the Five of Pentacles might signify resilience amidst adversity. It can emphasize the importance of inner strength and perseverance, suggesting that despite the external challenges, there is an inner resourcefulness that can be tapped into for resilience and growth.

With the Eight of Wands a reader might interpret the card as a symbol of swift action, indicating sudden developments, travel, or messages coming in quickly. It could signify a time of accelerated progress or events unfolding rapidly. Conversely, this card might represent the need for caution and mindful pacing. It could signal a situation where haste might lead to overlooking essential details or impulsive decisions, advising the seeker to proceed thoughtfully despite the sense of urgency.

Some readers interpret the Three of Cups as a card of celebration and joy, symbolizing gatherings, friendships, and harmonious connections. It could signify moments of shared happiness or successful collaborations. Another interpretation might focus on balance and moderation in social interactions. It could suggest the importance of healthy boundaries in relationships, warning against excessive indulgence or dependence on others for emotional fulfillment, as well as infidelity.

So, if you have been wondering why can tarot readers give you contrasting answers to the same question, the examples above illustrate how the same cards can evoke diverse meanings, offering nuanced insights depending on the reader’s perspective, the context of the reading, and the seeker’s situation. Tarot’s richness lies in its ability to resonate uniquely with each individual, offering multifaceted guidance and reflection through its symbolism and interpretations.


Rather than seeking a singular “correct” interpretation, embracing the diversity in tarot readings can be empowering. Each reading offers a unique perspective, inviting individuals to explore different facets of their situation. The variance in interpretations allows seekers to glean insights that resonate most profoundly with their intuition and circumstances. Ultimately, the beauty of tarot lies in its ability to spark introspection and offer guidance through varied lenses. Instead of focusing on discrepancies, embracing the richness of different interpretations fosters a deeper understanding of oneself and the situations at hand.

In conclusion, the variance in tarot readings springs from the intricate interplay of personal perspectives, contextual nuances, and the inherent depth of the cards themselves. This diversity enriches the tarot experience, inviting seekers to delve into the kaleidoscope of interpretations, seeking wisdom and guidance tailored to their unique journey.